California Energy Commission - 3 Nov 09

Prof. Robert B. Laughlin
Department of Physics
Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305

http://www.energy.ca.gov/siting/solar
(Copied 7 Dec 09)


Large Solar Energy Projects

California's electric utility companies are required to using renewable energy to produce 20 percent of their power by 2010 and 33 percent by 2020. A main source of renewable power will be solar energy.

Many large solar energy projects are being proposed in California's desert area on federal Bureau of Land Management (BLM) land. BLM has received right-of-way requests encompassing more than 300,000 acres for the development of approximately 34 large solar thermal power plants totaling approximately 24,000 megawatts. This number of projects have not yet reached the stage of an Application for Certification (AFC) with the California Energy Commission.

Solar thermal projects (above 50 MW) will require approvals from both the BLM and the Energy Commission prior to construction. Therefore, to provide joint National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA) and California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review and a more efficient process, the BLM and Energy Commission have entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) (PDF file, 14 pages, 140 kb). This MOU also has attachments listing the solar projects the BLM is aware of (as of July 2007) and the time line for the joint review process.

This Web section will provide information about projects under the Energy Commission's jurisdiction (thermal power plant projects 50 MW or larger) or information about smaller-sized plants under other agencies' jurisdiction. Wind farms are not thermal power plants and are not listed here. This page also will not list the many small photovoltaic (PV) projects under the California Solar Initiative or the New Solar Homes Partnership.

Solar Thermal Projects Under Review or Announced*
As of September 2, 2009


Solar Projects Currently Under Review by Energy Commission and BLM
Arranged by Date Application For Certification Was Filed

Project Name
and Applicant
Location Size & Technology
(megawatts)
Lead Agency Status*
Victorville 2 Hybrid Power Project
City of Victorville
Victorville 563 MW
513 MW natural gas
50 MW solar trough
Energy Commission APPROVED
AFC filed 2/28/07
Approved 7/16/08
Projects Approved - MW 50 MW    
Ivanpah Solar
Solar Partners/Brightsource
San Bernardino County 400 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC filed 8/31/07
Carrizo Energy Solar Farm
Carrizo Energy LLC
San Luis Obispo County 177 MW
Compact Linear Fresnel Reflector
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC filed 10/25/07
Beacon Solar Energy Project
Beacon Solar LLC
Kern County 250 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC filed 3/14/08
Solar Two Project
Tessera Solar (formerly Stirling Energy Systems)
Imperial County 750 MW
Stirling engine
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC filed 6/30/08
City of Palmdale Hybrid Gas-Solar
City of Palmdale
Palmdale 617 MW
555 MW natural gas
62 MW solar trough
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC Filed 8/4/08
San Joaquin Solar 1 & 2
San Joaquin Solar LLC
Fresno County 106.8 MW
solar trough / biomass hybrid
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC Filed 11/26/2008
Solar One Project
Tessera Solar (formerly Stirling Energy Systems)
San Bernardino County 850 MW
Stirling engine
Energy Commission Under Review
AFC Filed 12/2/2008
Abengoa Mojave Solar Project
Abengoa Solar Inc.
San Bernardino County 250 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission Pre-Review
AFC Filed 8/10/2009
Solar Millennium Palen
Solar Millennium LLC
Riverside County 484 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission Pre-Review
AFC Filed 8/24/2009
Solar Millennium Blythe
Solar Millennium LLC
Riverside County 1,000 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission Pre-Review
AFC Filed 8/24/2009
Genesis Solar
Genesis Solar LLC / NextEra Energy Resources LLC
Riverside County 250 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission Pre-Review
AFC Filed 8/31/2009
Solar Millennium Ridgecrest
Solar Millennium
Kern County 250 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission Pre-Review
AFC Filed 9/1/2009
Rice Solar Energy Project
Rice Solar LLC / SolarReserve LLC
Riverside County 150 MW
central tower
Energy Commission Pre-Review
AFC Filed 10/21/2009
Projects Under Review - MW 4,979.8 MW    

* AFC = Application For Certification is the license application filed with California Energy Commission for thermal power plants 50 megawatts or larger.



Projects "Announced" Or Have Signed Power Purchase Agreements*

Project Name
and Applicant
Location (megawatts) Lead Agency Status
Alpine Suntower
NRG and eSolar
Lancaster
Los Angeles County
92 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
BrightSource PPA5
BrightSource
Mojave 200 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
BrightSource PPA6
BrightSource
Mojave 200 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
BrightSource PPA7
BrightSource
Mojave 200 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
eSolar 1
eSolar
Los Angeles County 84 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
eSolar 2
eSolar
Los Angeles County 66 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Fort Irwin Solar Power Project
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Irwin Energy Security Partners LLC
San Bernardino County 1,000 MW
solar thermal and PV
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Gaskell SunTower
eSolar
Rosamond
Kern County
105 to 245 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Mojave Solar Park-1
Solel
Needles, Stedman or Arrowhead Junction
San Bernardino County
553.5 MW
solar trough
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Solar Partners XVI
Solar Partners / BrightSource
Ludlow and Siberia
San Bernardino County
200-220 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Solar Partners XVII
Solar Partners / BrightSource
Ludlow and Siberia
San Bernardino County
200-220 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Solar Partners XVIII
Solar Partners / BrightSource
Ludlow and Siberia
San Bernardino County
200-220 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Solar Partners XIX
Solar Partners / BrightSource
Ludlow and Siberia
San Bernardino County
200-220 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Solar Partners XX
Solar Partners / BrightSource
Ludlow and Siberia
San Bernardino County
200-220 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
Solar Partners XXI
Solar Partners / BrightSource
Ludlow and Siberia
San Bernardino County
200-220 MW
solar tower
Energy Commission AFC Not Yet Filed
TOTAL Announced MW 3,700.5 to 3,960.5 MW    
 
GRAND TOTAL MW (Under Review and "Announced")
 
10,183.3 to 10,443.3 MW
   

AFC = Application For Certification is the license application filed with California Energy Commission for thermal power plants 50 megawatts or larger.

* "Announced" refers to projects that have been publicly announced in the news media, have power purchase agreements pending with or approved by the CPUC, or ones that have made official declarations of intent.

List of Renewable Portfolio System Power Purchase Agreements - as of 17 Jul 09 (Spreadsheet 1.3 MB)

You can use the BLM's Geocommunicator website at www.geocommunicator.gov/NILS-PARCEL2/map.jsp?MAP=ENERGY to obtain information about the project developer and generate topo and aerial maps of the particular projects.


California Utility-Scale Solar Photovoltaic Projects (5 MW and Larger) and Smaller Solar Thermal Projects (less than 50 MW) Announced or On Line*
As of November 3, 2009

Project Name
and Applicant
Location (megawatts) Lead Agency Electricity Purchaser Estimated On-Line Date
Antelope Valley Solar Ranch
Nextlight Renewable Power LLC
Antelope Valley
Kern County
230 MW
(? technology)
Kern County PG&E 2018
California Valley Solar Ranch
SunPower LLC
California Valley
San Luis Obispo County
250 MW
(PV)
San Luis Obispo County PG&E 2018
CalRenew
CalRenew-1 LLC / Cleantech America
Mendota
Fresno County
5 MW
(? technology)
Fresno County PG&E 2013
Desert Sunlight
First Solar
Desert Center
Riverside County
250 MW
(thin film PV)
Fresno County SCE 2012
First Solar Energy 1
First Solar
Blythe
Kern County
7.5 MW
(thin-film PV)
Kern County PG&E 2013
High Plains Ranch II LLC
SunPower Inc
Carrisa Plains
San Luis Obispo County
210 MW
(monocrystalline silicon PV with single axis tracking)
San Luis Obispo County PG&E 2011 - 2012
(phase-in)
Kimberlina
Ausra
Bakersield 5 MW
Solar thermal
Compact Linear Fresnel Reflector
Kern County PG&E Online 20/23/08
KRCD Solar Farm
Kings River Conservation District / Cleantech America
Fresno County 80 MW
(? technology)
Fresno County San Joaquin Valley Power Authority 2011 - 2013
(phase-in)
Lucerne Valley Solar Project
Chevron Energy Solutions
8 miles east of Lucerne Valley
San Bernardino County
45 MW
(thin-film PV)
U.S. Bureau of Land Management ? 2011 - 2012
Sierra SunTower
eSolar
Antelope Valley 5 MW
(solar tower)
Los Angeles County SCE Operational 8/5/09
Solaren
Solaren
Fresno County 200 MW
(space-based solar collector)
Fresno County PG&E 2020
Stateline
First Solar
San Bernardio County 300 MW
(thin film PV)
San Bernardino County SCE 2013
Topaz Solar Farm
OptiSolar
Carrisa Plains
San Luis Obispo County
550 MW
(thin-film PV)
San Luis Obispo County PG&E 2011 - 2013
(phase-in)
TOTAL MW 2,137.5 MW  

* "Announced" refers to projects that have been publicly announced in or ones that have made official declarations of intent.

Note: These projects are under the local governmental jurisdiction and approval for conditional use permits or other needed licenses.




Background

California's Renewables Portfolio Standard (RPS) was established by Senate Bill 1078 (Sher, Chapter 516, Statutes of 2002). It required the state's retail sellers of electricity - investor-owned utilities (IOUs), electric service providers (ESPs), and community choice aggregators (CCAs) - to procure 20 percent of their retail electricity sales with eligible sources of renewable energy by 2017. California's energy agencies subsequently committed to achieving the 20 percent target by 2010; seven years earlier than the target.

This 20 percent target was codified by the enactment of Senate Bill 107 (Simitian and Perata, Chapter 464, Statutes of 2006), which took effect on January 1, 2007. A higher, more ambitious goal was initially set, by the Energy Commission and the Public Utilities Commission in the Energy Action Plan, at 33 percent renewables by 2017, but Governor Schwarzenegger's Executive Order of November 2008 set the goal at 33 percent by 2020.

In creating the RPS, the Legislature underscored the importance of increasing the diversity, reliability, public health, and environmental benefits of the energy mix.

To reach the 33 percent goal, each retail seller of electricity must increase the percentage of its electrical load served by renewable energy by at least 1.0 percent annually, with certain cost constraints. Under the law, retail sellers of electricity include the state's IOUs, ESPs, and CCAs, but does not include local publicly owned electric utilities.

For more about the Renewables Portfolio Standard, please go to the Energy Commission's website page at: www.energy.ca.gov/portfolio/.


Earlier Large, Solar Projects Producing Power

Prior to the Renewable Portfolio Standards in 2002, 13 solar thermal power projects were planned in California, with 11 of those filing applications with the Energy Commission. Nine projects (Solar Energy Generating Station - SEGS I to IX), totaling 354 MW, were built. SEGS III to IX are owned by NextEra Energy Resources (formerly FPL Energy), and SEGS I and II are owned by Cogentrix Solar Services - a wholly owned subsidiry of Cogentrix Energy LLC (Charlotte, NC), which purchased former owner Sunray Energy Inc. in early 2009.

One large photovoltaic (PV) array was built by the Sacramento Municipal Utility District near its Rancho Seco Nuclear Plant. It went on line in August 1984 and has an installed capacity of 3.19 MW.


Project Name Capacity In MW CEC Docket Number Location County Date Certified On-Line Date
SOLAR 100 110.0 81-AFC-4   San Bernardino 12/29/82 Never built - land use issues
Luz SEGS I
Solar/Nat Gas
13.8 Local Jurisdiction
Under 50 MW
Daggett San Bernardino   12/20/84
Luz SEGS II
Solar/Nat Gas
30 Local Jurisdiction
Under 50 MW
Daggett San Bernardino   12/31/85
Luz SEGS III-VII
Solar/Nat Gas)
150.0

5 X 30 MW
87-AFC-1 Kramer Junction San Bernardino 5/25/88 2/1/89
Luz SEGS VIII
Solar/Nat Gas
80.0 88-AFC-1 Harper Dry Lake San Bernardino 3/29/89 12/1/89
Luz SEGS IX
Solar/Nat Gas
80.0 89-AFC-1 Harper Dry Lake San Bernardino 2/14/90 10/1/90
Luz SEGS X
Solar/Nat Gas
80.0 89-AFC-1 Harper Dry Lake San Bernardino Suspended
5/13/1992
Construction halted - company bankruptcy
Luz SEGS XI
Solar/Nat Gas
80.0 89-AFC-2 Harper Dry Lake San Bernardino Suspended
5/13/1992
Never built - company bankruptcy
Luz SEGS XII
Solar/Nat Gas
80.0 91-AFC-1 Harper Dry Lake San Bernardino Suspended
5/13/1992
Never built - company bankruptcy
Solar One

and

Solar Two
10.0 n/a Daggett San Bernardino n/a The Solar One central tower research facility was completed in 1981 and was operational from 1982 to 1986.
Solar Two added more mirrors and was operational from 1995 to 1999.

Last Modified: 11/03/09
Solar Two - Aerial view of the Solar One & Two facility near Daggett, California. The 10 megawatt solar tower research facility was closed in 1999. Picture courtesy of Google Earth.